The Problem With Eating Processed Foods Prior To Remission

Feel free to discuss any topic of general interest, so long as nothing you post here is likely to be interpreted as insulting, and/or inflammatory, nor clearly designed to provoke any individual or group. Please be considerate of others feelings, and they will be considerate of yours.

Moderators: Rosie, Stanz, Jean, CAMary, moremuscle, JFR, Dee, xet, Peggy, Matthew, Gabes-Apg, grannyh, Gloria, Mars, starfire, Polly, Joefnh

Post Reply
User avatar
tex
Site Admin
Site Admin
Posts: 35349
Joined: Tue May 24, 2005 9:00 am
Location: Central Texas

The Problem With Eating Processed Foods Prior To Remission

Post by tex »

Hi All,

The biggest problem with processed foods is that they simply can't be trusted. If we're trying to control our MC symptoms by diet, and we're including a significant number of processed foods in our choices, the odds are fairly good that we may be eating contaminated food. The more processed foods we eat, the greater our chances of being "glutened", or "casined", or "soyed", or "whatevered"

Unfortunately, it's a sad fact of life, that we may never be able to achieve remission, if one of the foods that we eat regularly, is contaminated. That's why it's always best to eat either no processed foods, or as few as possible, while we're initially trying to get our symptoms under control.

If we want to try processed foods after we're in remission, that's relatively safe and easy to do, because once we're in remission, it's easy to tell if a food is contaminated - it will cause symptoms. If we're already having symptoms to begin with, though, it's impossible to tell if a food is contaminated, so if we continue to eat a contaminated food, we will remain symptomatic indefinitely, which is an unfortunate and sad state or affairs, but I have a hunch that it happen much more frequently than we realize.

Why? Because most people who are newly diagnosed with this disease, have to be dragged "kicking and screaming" to the GF diet. That's not surprising, because no one wants to have to change the diet that they have enjoyed for so many years, especially when it requires cutting out so many of the foods that they love to eat, and which they have eaten all their life. So what do they do - naturally, they try to find GF substitutes for the foods that they are accustomed to eating. They want the products to look the same, and taste the same. And that means, they want processed foods. Cooking from scratch isn't even on many people's radar, these days. Our grandparents did it all the time, but these days, we think that food should premixed, ready to cook with as few steps as possible.

IMO, next to the habit of eating out, cooking with processed foods is one of the most common stumbling blocks that can prevent us from reaching remission. The problem is that the deck is stacked against us when we use processed foods. First off, we have to carefully read the label, and if we happen to miss a single ingredient that we can't tolerate, we've already gone astray before we even start cooking.

A second pitfall becomes a risk when we learn to trust a product, because we know that it works for us, and then one fine day, without warning, that manufacturer decides to change an ingredient or two, (which seems to happen rather frequently these days, with many products), and we fall into the trap, by failing to read the label every time.

The most frustrating risk, though, is one that's totally beyond our control, and that's the increasing risk of undeclared allergens in processed foods. As more and more manufacturers outsource ingredients from the far corners of the earth, and ingredient suppliers are changed frequently, the risk of contaminated ingredients is rising dramatically. This recall report is representative of what's happening:
Undeclared allergens were the most common cause of food recalls during the quarter, accounting for more than 45 percent of all food recalls. The number of recalls initiated because of undeclared allergens exceeded the total number of recalls for the pathogens Salmonella, Botulism and Listeria combined. Salmonella was the second leading cause of food recalls during the quarter.
http://www.prnewswire.com/news-releases ... 16448.html

When we cook from scratch, we can buy locally, from a trusted supplier, and we can even cook from our own garden. But when we buy processed foods, we typically have no control over where the various ingredients may come from, because they literally come from everywhere - all over the world. They come from wherever the processor could find the cheapest quote, that would meet their needs, at the time that they contracted those supplies. Can we seriously think that a supplier in Timbuktu, (or wherever), is going to decline an opportunity to make a big sale to a processor, just because they cannot be absolutely sure that a batch or two of the ingredient that they are offering for sale might not carry a risk of cross-contamination? Times are tough - they have to sell their products, if they're going to put food on their own tables.

Anyway, I just want to point out that if we're really serious about achieving remission, cooking from scratch can do wonders toward reaching that goal. Back when I was floundering around, trying to "eat my way back to health", I discovered that regardless of how safe the label looked, if the product contained more than 4 or 5 ingredients, I would react to it, virtually every time. It finally dawned on me that I needed to avoid all that stuff, if I intended to get my life back.

Now, after being in remission for years, I can eat processed foods, if I want, because even if the label is wrong, I will know almost immediately, and I won't make that mistake a second time. I occasionally eat GF cereals, and a few other things, but for the most part, I still mostly cook from scratch. After all, if we cook from scratch, then for all practical purposes, our GF, DF, SF, etc., food is really no more expensive than the food that everyone else is eating. Except for baking, of course, but since I've always viewed baked products as mostly desert items, anyway, we shouldn't get upset about having to pay more for deserts and specialty foods.

Love,
Tex
:cowboy:

It is suspected that some of the hardest material known to science can be found in the skulls of GI specialists who insist that diet has nothing to do with the treatment of microscopic colitis.
User avatar
sarkin
Rockhopper Penguin
Rockhopper Penguin
Posts: 2313
Joined: Thu Mar 10, 2011 8:44 pm
Location: Brooklyn, NY

Post by sarkin »

Tex,

I'm sure you won't be surprised to hear that I heartily agree! I think it's also unhelpful, psychologically, to keep eating foods that resemble the gluten enemy... for two reasons: 1) clinging to those foods is keeping your attention on what you're missing (and many folks are really unhappy with the different quality, which means you feel bad about eating those things all the time), and 2) if you really have to have a sandwich, or 'breading' in a certain dish, at some point you may be tempted to choose a packaged product when you don't have your reading glasses... or to rely on a product that has worked before, without re-double-checking the label... if the label is even complete and accurate. I have always felt the same way about artificial sweeteners... aside from the important fact that they are not food, they keep people trained to "need" a level of sweetness that's not especially healthy. Eating without that sweetness, your tastebuds grow up to enjoy the natural flavors in foods.

I eat almost entirely home-cooked, but we do eat out - and that is certainly my greatest risk factor. I'm not quite at the point of asking friends not to bring food into my home that is toxic to me, but I will do that if it comes down to it. My husband agrees, on principle, that there are two options: an absolutely safe and workable way of segregating all food & preparation involving gluten, dairy, eggs and legumes from anything that might touch anything that I might touch. Or we just cannot have it in the house. Most people will attempt to find something I can eat, but I don't want to eat a 'product' of any kind, and I don't want my friends picking up something GF from a bakery (those places, last I checked, are full of flour), and I don't want to have another conversation explaining that "no dairy" means, actually, no dairy - yogurt counts, cheese counts, butter counts.

I eat at restaurants that work for me. I am willing to try a new restaurant, but if I am not confident in the quality of communication and listening on the part of the staff, I don't eat there. Last week I had a post-meeting stop in a pub near my friends, and there was not one thing on that menu I would put in my mouth - I would bet you that everything that's not battered and fried is nonetheless fried in that same oil where the batter goes, AND that pretty much everything in that kitchen comes out of a frozen package from a processing facility. This is a beer bar, not a fresh-local-gastro kind of place. I wish them the best, and it would be ridiculous for me to expect them to find something in that kitchen they could call safe. (I bet if there is one thing, it's iceberg lettuce... no thanks!) I had a glass of wine and excused myself.

If I eat somewhere and have any doubt, I just don't go back there. That, plus keeping it rare and eating only small meals, is working for now. If I weren't making progress, I would absolutely eliminate that practice entirely.

My friend brought takeout dinner for her kids, so we could squeeze in a visit - these are the kids whose Enterolab results are in process. I can see her struggling with what she's going to feed them when she gets their results. I can also see them *loving* what I'm eating. If you don't put packaged food in someone's hands and then take it away, it's a lot less painful for all concerned. We were making "meat cupcakes" (as my husband calls them) - what kid wouldn't want that? What adult, for that matter?

:ChefStirringPot:

Bon appetit to all,

Sara
Polly
Moderator
Moderator
Posts: 5185
Joined: Wed May 25, 2005 3:34 am
Location: Maryland

Post by Polly »

Beautifully said, Tex.

And so very true. I thought of another reason.......the fact that an allergen does not have to be listed in a processed food if it is present in less than a certain amount, and many of us react to even miniscule amounts.

I have really learned to enjoy making food from scratch, and I have become much more creative in the process. Yesterday I made a batch of ground turkey "sausage" patties that I precooked and froze. Now I can nuke one quickly in the microwave for breakfast. And they are so tasty made with ginger, sage, a pinch of cayenne pepper, etc. The day before that I made a soup with roasted zucchini, eggplant, and onion; chicken broth; rosemary; and chopped walnuts. After cooking, I pureed it, and Scott thinks it is one of the best soups he's ever eaten! Tonite I am making stuffed peppers with red pepper sauce (I am sensitive to tomatoes).

When I first got my MRT results 6 mo. ago and learned of so many unsuspected sensitivities, I was really bummed. But the silver lining is that I have learned to eat and enjoy many foods that were not part of my usual diet. And have become a much better cook in the process. I have learned to think out of the box.

Thanks for bringing up this important topic.

Love,

Polly

P.S. Hi Sara :wave: Enjoyed your input, as usual.
Blessed are they who can laugh at themselves, for they shall never cease to be amused.
User avatar
mbeezie
Rockhopper Penguin
Rockhopper Penguin
Posts: 1500
Joined: Fri May 29, 2009 3:14 am
Location: Texas

Post by mbeezie »

Great topic!

I am a big fan of cooking from scratch and do believe it is one of the reasons I feel great most of the time. Like Sara, I quickly gave up on trying to make gluten look-alikes. Of course that stuff still works its way into my house because I have an 11 year old, but he is an athlete and I have already started talking to him about the benefits of paleo. But I have to admit that even I was a bit overwhelmed at first with the amount of scratch cooking I had to do. It takes organization and planning and a large freeezer (Polly, I make and freeze my own breakfast sausage too - much better than store bought).

I have found a handful of safe restaurants but mostly we eat at home, with lots of fresh fruit and veggies. Well meaning friends try and I always feel bad when I can't eat something they made especailly for me. However, most recently a group of friends threw a birthday party/luau for me and I was able to eat nearly everything they made. They roasted a pig for their cave dwelling friend and I realized they were finally getting it.

I wish I could convince others that cooking from scratch and paleo are the tools needed for good health, but they aren't ready (or sick enough I guess) for that drastic of a change. Just today I was reveling in the fact that my son discovered he loved kale soup. How would he ever know that he loved kale if I didn't cook it?? Certainly not in a frozen dinner or fast food restaurant. He's can also do some basic cooking and this will expand as he gets older.

Stuffed peppers sound good Polly (I can't eat tomatoes either so the pepper sauce sounds wonderful). I just picked a few peppers from my garden and was thinking about what I could do with them and I think that will be on the menu this week.

Mary Beth
"If you believe it will work out, you'll see opportunities. If you believe it won't you will see obstacles." - Dr. Wayne Dyer
User avatar
sarkin
Rockhopper Penguin
Rockhopper Penguin
Posts: 2313
Joined: Thu Mar 10, 2011 8:44 pm
Location: Brooklyn, NY

Post by sarkin »

Hmmm, maybe I can eat peppers? I have been avoiding them. But if Polly & Mary Beth are on board...

KIDDING - of course, we are all different, time (and MRT) will tell. Polly, your point about miniscule amounts is so important. Part of my light-hearted "haz-mat" procedures are meant to highlight that it is not benign when gluten (in particular) is flying around my kitchen. If you hand me a jar of almond butter that you picked up with your wheat-y sandwich hand, then even if I'm watching the knives like a hawk (which, believe me, I am), I now have gluten on my hand. Which I eat with. My husband's a lot more mindful and has mostly Sara-safe kitchen habits, but I don't always feel like educating guests... nor hosts.

Mary Beth, I know how terrible you feel when someone makes or purchases something special, but it isn't going to work. The convention is to take a "no-thank-you" helping, but the convention is a lot less important than whatever I'd rather do than spend the next week recovering.

I suspect I am eating better than just about anyone we know - not in terms of anyone's definition of good/right/healthy (though probably that, too), but having really nice meals, as opposed to grabbing what's available and being a little dissatisfied by the choices. I've definitely had trouble keeping my fresh fruits/veg consumption down, at this time of year. I'm dialing that back, and by the time the giant winter squashes become available, I'm sure I'll be ready for some nice slow cooking :smile:

A neighbor told my husband recently that whatever 'regimen' I'm 'doing' seems to be working, because I look great. I think that's mostly just friendly noise (friendly noise is part of what holds a neighborhood together, I'm all for it). But this is someone who's been just shy of hostile/dismissive, in the past. (In fairness, she wasn't mean or foolish enough to do that twice.) So I think this means we're all moving on, in the right direction.

Love,
Sara
Post Reply

Return to “Main Message Board”